[TNT!MEN] [Events] [News] [Weather] [Media Archive] [About TNT!MEN] [Spike's Naked Planet]
To TNT!MEN Home Page


TNT!MEN

Spike's Journal of TNT!MEN Events 

PREVIOUS  |  INDEX  |  NEXT

How You Can Help Protect Nude Events in Canada (19 June 2000)

This is an open call for your letters of support to ALL people who support recreational nude events in Canada, whether you live in Toronto or not. All letters of support will help.

Community Action Committee
TNT!MEN
June 19, 2000

Dear Fellow Nudists and Supporters of Nudism:

We are writing to you on behalf of the Community Action Committee of TNT!MEN with an urgent and important request: We need you to please write to the following people at City Hall to state your objections to recent police behaviour relating to nudity at TNT!MEN events at The Barn.

The people who need to hear from you are: (addresses below)

  1. Councillor Norm Gardner, Chair of the Police Services Board
  2. Mayor Mel Lastman
  3. Councillor Olivia Chow
  4. Councillor Kyle Rae, our friend and supporter
  5. your city councillors
  6. please send a copy to us as well.
     

Writing Your Letter

  1. Use your own words. A letter in your own words is most effective. It shows real concern and that you are willing to take some time out of a full and busy life to address something you really believe in. Form letters have only limited effect.
     
  2. A hand-written letter carries more weight than a typed letter. However, typed letters are also effective.
     
  3. Faxes are good -- but letters are better. If you prefer to fax, however, do it. Faxed letters get there very quickly.
     
  4. E-mail is also effective, though less so than #s 1, 2, or 3.
     

Some Points to Consider

  • Police visits to nudist events in clubs represents an irresponsible or frivolous use of police dollars and time, especially when there are more important and relevant things that the police could be doing.
     
  • Targeting naked events which have run for four years without incident is, to say the least, strange. Why now? Is there a bias here?
     
  • Nudism is a world-wide movement whose practitioners include people of all classes and races.
     
    • Naked events and gatherings occur without harassment in many parts of the world.
       
    • Nudism provides a healthy, peaceful way of relating to one another.
       
  • Naked events have been a tremendous boost for business in the clubs where they occur, just as having a clothing-optional beach at Hanlan's Point has been a financial benefit to the city.
     
  • Naked events at clubs are good for good for tourism. TNT!MEN's events -- through their promotion via the internet -- have attracted visitors from allover North America, Europe and Australia.
     
  • Nudism is morally acceptable. Only in the eyes of the prurient it is it always associated with sex.
     
  • Naked events are fun.

You probably have many more ideas. Put them to good use in your letter.
 

Petitions

As well as letters, we will be soliciting signatures on two petitions, one directed to the Police Services Board from residents of Toronto and the other from visitors to Toronto directed toward the City's tourism office. They will demand the immediate cessation of police harassment and intimidation of naked or clothing-optional events and the premises where they occur, including those which are licensed. These will be available on Pride Day.

We believe that only through making our views heard can we bring this abuse to a halt.

Please try to make time to write your letter. It will make a difference.

Walter Cavalieri
on behalf of the Community Action Committee of TNT!MEN
His Worship, the Mayor of Toronto
Mr. Mel Lastman
Toronto City Hall, 2nd floor
100 Queen St. West
Toronto, ON
M5H 2N2

Phone: (416) 395-6464
Fax: (416) 395-6440
E-mail: mayor_lastman@city.toronto.on.ca
Councillor Norm Gardner, Chair
Toronto Police Service Board
Toronto City Hall
100 Queen St. West, Suite B28
Toronto, M5H 2N2

Phone: (416) 392-4018
Fax: (416) 392-4120

E-mail: councillor_gardner@city.toronto.on.ca
Councillor Olivia Chow
Toronto City Hall
100 Queen St. West, Suite C50
Toronto, M5H 2N2

Phone: (416) 392-4044
Fax: (416) 392-4130

E-mail: councillor_chow@city.toronto.on.ca
Councillor Kyle Rae
Toronto City Hall
100 Queen Street West, Suite A5
Toronto, M5H 2N2

Phone: (416) 392-7903
Fax: (416) 696-4300

E-mail: councillor_rae@city.toronto.on.ca

If you live in the Downtown ward, your councillors are Kyle Rae and Olivia Chow.

If you live in the new mega-city of Toronto, but not downtown, you can phone the city at (416) 338-0338 during office hours to find out the names of your councillors.

Alternatively, looking at the start of the Blue Pages in the Toronto phone directory, you'll see a map showing Toronto wards as well as a list of councillors sorted by ward name. (page 21)

A full list of city councillors is available on the City of Toronto web page. You can check to see if you recognize anyone listed there. The URL is http://www.city.toronto.on.ca/council/councillors.htm.


Spike's Letter

June 20th, 2000

Mr. Mel Lastman,
His Worship, the Mayor of Toronto
Toronto City Hall, 2nd Floor
100 Queen St. West
Toronto ON M5H 2N2

Dear Mr. Lastman,

I am quite disturbed at the way a few police officers have been wasting my tax dollars by attempting to shut down peaceful, legal nudist events at a downtown club. It reminds me very much of the international embarrassment caused last summer by four police officers who cited an obsolete bylaw and chased several dozen naked swimmers out of the water at HanlanÍs Point last summer. That story was reported in newspapers around the world.

This year, a few officers in 52 Division have been visiting The Barn on a monthly basis since February, trying to stop TNT!MEN from holding its monthly nude dance. Despite a complete lack of interest from the Alcohol and Gaming Commission and an agreement with Supt. Aidan Maher of 52 Division, the officers have twisted the interpretation of a regulation under the liquor licence act, and they are using this as a club to beat The Barn into submission. As a result, the owner of The Barn is feeling too intimidated to continue holding nude events, even though Supt. Maher has promised no further police interference on this point. This is not serving and protecting the public. Instead, a few police officers are trying to impose their personal preferences on taxpayers and citizens who are breaking no laws and hurting no-one.

I would like to see police fighting real crime, where people are actually being hurt. I do not want them wasting my tax dollars by treating peaceful people as criminals.

Sincerely,

DD.

cc: Norm Gardner, Olivia Chow, Kyle Rae, Jack Layton, Pam McConnell

 

Walter's Letter

June 27, 2000

Councillor Norm Gardner
Chair, Toronto Police Service Board
Toronto City Hall
100 Queen St. West, Suite B28
Toronto, M5H 2N2


Dear Councillor Gardner:

I am writing to you to express my very serious objections to police behaviour relating to nudity at monthly dances at The Barn, a gay club on Church Street. These dances have occurred monthly for over three years, under the sponsorship of TNT!MEN (Totally Naked Toronto Men Enjoying Nudity). They have been orderly and peaceable. They have been very well attended. They have attracted people from all over North America and from as far away as Europe and Australia. They have never spawned any hostile incidents or generated any complaints.

As you may know, police officers acting as agents of the Alcohol and Gaming Commission, visited these naked dances on three occasions, laying a charge (which will be addressed in court later this year) of "disorderly conduct" after one of these visits, merely because the people attending the dance were nude -- a reality that has never been kept secret. TNT!MEN is, after all, a nudist group, legitimate, registered under the Corporations Act and a member of the Canadian Federation of Naturists, with over 300 members.

The following is a chronology of what has happened to date.

Feb 26, 2000: Two plainclothes police officers showed up at The Barn at 11:30 pm. They claimed they were responding to TNT!MEN's street posters. They were carrying one of them, which they had apparently picked up somewhere on their beat, and claimed that they were looking for naked people. They found none, because the dance had finished three hours earlier. As the poster clearly stated, the dance takes place from 4:00 to 8:30 pm. The officers mentioned to a Barn staff something about nude bar events being a violation of the liquor license act, and then left.

Mar 25, 2000: The two police officers came back during the next TNT!MEN naked dance at The Barn. This time the event was in full swing, with over 200 naked men dancing and chatting and having a very sociable time. Later that week the police placed a charge against The Barn's owner, Janko Naglic, for violating a section of the liquor license act, by permitting nudity in a licensed premise.

Early April, 2000: Peter Simm, TNT!MEN's lawyer and an internationally respected expert on nudity law, drafted a thoroughly researched report which powerfully detailed four extremely compelling reasons why the police are incorrect in their interpretation of the liquor license act and are distorting its meaning. A copy of this report was passed on to Andrew Czernik (The Barn's lawyer) and to city councillor Kyle Rae. Rae then personally hand-delivered a copy to Police Supt. Maher of 52 Division and to the head of the Alcohol & Gaming Commission. Supt. Maher, in turn, gave a copy of it to the Crown Attorney's office.

April 7, 2000: At Kyle Rae's suggestion, Mr. Czernik called Supt. Maher. In that conversation, Supt. Maher proposed the following solution that, according to his understanding of the law, would enable TNT!MEN to continue hosting nude dances unmolested: Supt. Maher promised that no police action would be brought against The Barn for holding licensed nude events if those events were conducted as private parties. By this he meant that tickets to the party must not be available at the door, but must be purchased in advance, or elsewhere. The Barn agreed, and TNT!MEN carefully implemented the requirements of that deal for their next dance, on Saturday April 29th.

April 29, 2000: Despite this agreement, Det. David Wilson (52 Division) and two plainclothes officers showed up at the TNT!MEN nude dance on April 29th, and claimed to know nothing about Supt. Maher's "private party" plan. After a prolonged and zealous search for regulatory infractions, the three police officers left without finding anything to complain about.

Mr. Naglic has found it prudent to cancel all naked events at The Barn. He cannot risk the costs associated with repeated police harassment. As well, naked events at other gay clubs are also being curtailed.

Exactly how much did this last visit by the police to a harmless event cost the City of Toronto? Probably several thousand dollars. And why this intense harassment of a benign and popular monthly event which, I repeat, has never -- NEVER -- over its entire history caused incident or evoked complaint?

I am not going to make a long case for nudity here. There is plenty of published material available, and I am certain you can access it, should you wish to. I do want to point out a couple of things.

As a person who has been a nudist for 30 years, and as a therapist / counsellor, I can attest to the healthfulness of nudism. Nudism demystifies the body and mollifies the sense of shame that people so often associate with their bodies -- a factor which leads to all sorts of abuse. Nudism nurtures respect for the body, in all its variances -- while at the same time honouring the boundaries of propriety which are socially prescribed. It also subverts class and marginality, bringing about a more egalitarian way for to relate -- not as roles or costumes, but as people. It is also a popular activity. You have merely to look at the public response to Hanlan' s Point for acknowledgement of this. Turning Hanlan's Point into a clothing-optional beach has brought large numbers of respectable people to a location which had been essentially unused to swim or sun-bathe without clothing. To the best of my knowledge, there have been no incidents and no complaints as a result of this urban initiative.

Nudists who live in Toronto have had few opportunities to convene and socialise within the city. For gay nudists, the opportunities have been even more scarce. The success of TNT!MEN's dances attests to both the popularity of and the need for naked events of this sort, and also demonstrates that they clearly reflect the community's standards -- just as does Hanlan's Point.

That the police have taken time to pursue issues of spurious moralism or to act out their disdain for gay men (I can think of no other reasons) is foolish and wasteful, especially in the face of their claim -- probably just -- that they cannot keep up with such important public responsibilities as keeping the peace and preventing crime.

Finally, I wish to state that I have a vested interest in the continuity of these events and in seeing the police call of their persecution of gay nudist activities in clubs -- licensed or not. I am President of Board of TNT!MEN. Were that not the case, however, I would still be writing this letter.

Sincerely,

Walter Cavalieri
MSc, MSW, RSW

cc: Mayor Mel Lastman
Councillor Olivia Chow
Councillor Kyle Rae
TNT!MEN

 

From Norm Gardner Received July 10th

Toronto Police Services Board
40 College Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. M5G 2J3
(416) 808-8080 FAX (416) 808-8082
www.torontopoliceboard.on.ca

NORMAN GARDNER, Chairman

June 29, 2000

Dear Mr. D:

Thank you for your letter dated June 20, 2000, regarding policing of the Barn.

The concerns you have raised pertain specifically to operational policing matters, which fall within the jurisdiction of the Chief of Police rather than the Board. Therefore, I have forwarded your correspondence to the attention of Chief Julian Fantino for his review and any action he deems appropriate.

I trust the appropriate Service personnel will respond to you shortly regarding your concerns.

Thank you for bringing your concerns to my attention.

Yours truly,

Norman Gardner
Chairman

c.c. Chief Julian Fantino

 

From Mel Lastman Received 21 July

Mel Lastman, Mayor
City of Toronto
Tel: (416) 395-6464
Fax: (416) 395-6440
mayor_lastman@city.toronto.on.ca

July 12, 2000


Dear Mr. D:

Thank you for your letter of June 20, 2000, conveying your dissatisfaction with police officers from 52 Division attempting to shut down a monthly nudist event at The Barn.

I have forwarded a copy of your letter to Chief Julian Fantino, Toronto Police Service, for his review and appropriate action.

Once again, Mr. D, thank you for writing and expressing your views. Please accept my warmest personal regards and have a great summer.

Cordially,

Mel Lastman
Mayor

copy: Chief Julian Fantino, Toronto Police Service

 

From Office of the Chief of Police Received 26 July

Toronto Police Service
40 College Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. M5G 2J3
(416) 808-2222 FAX (416) 808-8202
Website: www.TorontoPolice.on.ca

Julian Fantino
Chief of Police

July 21, 2000


Dear Mr. D:

The Office of the Chief of Police is in receipt of your correspondence addressed to Mayor Mel Lastman dated June 20, 2000. Chief Julian Fantino would like to thank you for taking the time to write and express your concerns regarding The Barn and officers at 52 Division.

A copy of your correspondence has been forwarded to Deputy Chief Michael Boyd, Central Field Command, for his attention. A member of his area of command will contact you in the near future.

Sincerely,

Wayne Cotgreave, Inspector
Executive Officer
Office of the Chief of Police

To Serve and Protect - Working with the Community

 

From Councillor Kyle Rae Received 14 August

Kyle Rae, Councillor
City Hall, 2nd Floor
100 Queen Street West
Toronto, Ontario M5H 2N2

Tel: (416) 392-7903
Fax: (416) 696-4300
councillor_rae@city.toronto.on.ca

August 10, 2000

Dear Mr. D,

RE: Social Meetings of TNT!MEN

Sorry for taking so long in responding to your letter however, I have been in discussion with the Police concerning their interventions at The Barn and The Toolbox. In addition, I have had discussions with Councillor Jack Layton concerning The Toolbox incident. During last week's Council meeting, I was able to ask Chief Fantino about the Police actions and I am awaiting his response to my concerns.

As you know, there is a court date set in the fall to deal with the Police interpretation of the Liquor Licence Act as it pertains to nude socializing. It is clear that this area of the law has never been pursued in Ontario before and therefore, will be an important opportunity for the nudist community to organize and defend its activities. It is particularly important for nudist clubs across the country that have liquor licensed premises at their resorts to get involved in this case.

As you know, I have been a strong supported of your group in its attempts to create safe space for you to enjoy your pastime. Hanlan's Point has been a great success and I look forward to the time when your group can, without harassment, hold social events at bars. I will continue to support your group and am embarrassed by the actions taken by certain members of the Toronto Police Service.

I remain,

Kyle Rae
City Councillor - Downtown

Norm's Letter

July 27, 2000

Councillor Norm Gardner, Chair
Police Services Board
Toronto City Hall
100 Queen St. West
Toronto, Ontario M5H 2N2

Dear Mr. Gardner;

I am writing to you as a nudist who has regularly attended the TNT!MEN (Totally Naked Toronto Men Enjoying Nudity) dances at The Barn on Church Street every month for the last three years. I am also a father of three and grandfather of six who believes that the negative attitudes about the human body in our North American society do more harm than good.

In February, two police officers from 52 Division spoke with the management of The Barn and warned them that the naked dances of TNT!MEN must be stopped. When the March event went ahead, officers again entered the premises and subsequently laid a charge of "permitting disorderly conduct" solely on the basis that, during this party, all the people in the bar (except the staff) were naked.

In April, when the event was held as a "private party" with tickets that were sold in advance (a suggestion which Sup't Maher of 52 Div. had made, saying that this would satisfy the police), three officers spent considerable time on a "routine inspection" during the TNT!MEN dance - "routine" on the only day of each month when the bar is open between 4:00 and 8:30 pm.

At a time when the City now has a clothing-optional beach where men, women and children can sun, swim and socialize naked in the open in broad daylight, it seems a remarkable kind of prudery for the police to suggest that nude dancing and socializing is "disorderly" simply because it takes place inside a licensed premises!

In its summer issue of "Going Natural", the Federation of Canadian Naturists (FCN), which represents thousands of naturist/nudist couples and families across Canada, indicated that "if this charge stuck, it would mean that every naturist club in Ontario (and who knows where else) that held a liquor license would have to either give up the license or ban nudity."

Mr. Gardner, I am asking that the Police Services Board raise concerns about the amount of police officer time that has been spent on this issue.

Considering the fact that these dances have been going on for the past three years and that there have been no problems or incidents of actual disorderly conduct, violence or drunkenness, could we have assurance that the police will leave these events alone - at least until the court has had the opportunity to rule on the validity of the officers' contention that mere nudity by the attendees at such an event constitutes "disorderly conduct" in and of itself?

Sincerely,

J. Norman Rickaby

cc: His Worship, Mayor Mel Lastman
Councillor Kyle Rae
Councillor Olivia Chow

 


The page was created by Spike.

Last Update: Thursday 17 May 2001
Home Site: www.nakedplanet.org
This page is http://tntmen.abuzar.net/tnt/news/f01.html